Ghosted job seekers don’t forget: 48% say they wouldn’t apply to that company again

Ghosted job seekers don’t forget: 48% say they wouldn’t apply to that company again

In a tough job market, you can spend hours researching a company, preparing for interviews, completing skills tests, providing references, and meeting with hiring managers over several rounds. Then comes an email along the lines of: “Unfortunately, we’ve decided not to move forward with your application. We wish you the best of luck.”

Two sentences. No acknowledgment of the hours you invested or the people you met. Or worse, you never hear back. The rejection itself may sting, but the indifference can feel even worse.

Companies spend significant time and money building their employer brands, trying to convince job seekers they’re great places to work. Yet after candidates invest hours in the hiring process, some employers can’t spare a few minutes to write a rejection email that sounds human. Moving on may seem efficient, but research suggests the neglect carries a cost for both future hires and customers.

“When employers spend money on branding, but don’t focus on the candidate experience, they’re missing out on the big picture,” Vicki Salemi, a career expert at Monster who previously worked in corporate recruiting, told Fortune.

A generic rejection erodes a strong employer brand

A study published in February in the International Journal of Selection and Assessment found that a generic rejection email can significantly reduce how attractive a company appears to prospective employees. A more appreciative message, however, can help preserve that appeal.

“The higher the employer brand equity, the more to lose with sending a generic rejection email,” Sanne Fijneman-Ghielen, a researcher at Tilburg University and the study’s lead author, told Fortune.

The researchers surveyed 236 working adults and final-year students in the Netherlands and Belgium, asking them to evaluate prospective employers before and after receiving hypothetical rejection letters.

For participants presented with a company with a strong employer brand, attractiveness scores fell from 3.29 to 2.61 after receiving a standard rejection letter. A few days later, the score had recovered to 2.89 but remained significantly below its original level.

By contrast, participants who received an appreciative rejection letter showed no statistically significant decline in their perception of the employer.

Rejected candidates are also customers

A rejection email might seem like a minor administrative task. But the consequences of a poor candidate experience can extend well beyond hiring.

In an April LiveCareer survey of 1,008 U.S. workers, 48% said they wouldn’t apply to a company again after being ghosted, 42% said they would trust the company less, and 37% said they would share the experience with others. Ghosting is getting more common: 53% of job seekers were ghosted by an employer in the past year, a three-year high, according to a report from Criteria.

A July survey of ghosted applicants by recruitment assessment company Selection Lab found that 34.1% had told friends or family about it and 22.3% said they would never apply to the company again. Another 4.2% shared the experience online, and 2.6% had stopped buying the company’s products or services.

Other research puts the customer risk higher. In an August PeopleScout survey of more than 1,000 job seekers across 10 markets, 36% of candidates who had a negative hiring experience said they would stop purchasing from that company, and 37% would discourage others from applying.

Salemi said candidates who feel respected during the hiring process may still apply for future openings, recommend the company to friends, or remain loyal customers. Those who feel dismissed may do the opposite.

Recruiter workloads are the reason, not the excuse

A thoughtful rejection email takes minutes and can help protect a company’s reputation. Many employers still don’t send one, a gap that Greenhouse’s chief people officer warned in 2023 could come back to bite them.

Salemi pointed to recruiting workloads. Recruiters often manage multiple job openings simultaneously, review hundreds or thousands of resumes, coordinate interviews, and track hiring metrics such as time-to-fill. Communicating with rejected candidates can fall through the cracks.

She doesn’t consider that an excuse, and technology is making the task easier. In a September post on the Greenhouse blog, Melissa Shannon, a recruiter at the hiring software company, described using AI to draft personalized rejection emails for candidates who had completed onsite interviews.

The tool reads interview scorecards and notes to draft messages that acknowledge candidates’ strengths and areas for development, and a recruiter checks each draft for accuracy before it goes out. Shannon wrote that the process cut drafting time from 20 to 30 minutes per candidate to less than three.

“Ultimately, rejecting finalist candidates comes down to priorities and accountability,” Salemi said. “This stems from the top—from leadership and the company culture.”

What an appreciative rejection letter says

Salemi offered an example of a particularly bad rejection email sent after multiple rounds of interviews:

“Dear Applicant, Thank you for your interest. We have decided to not continue with your candidacy. Good luck in your job search.”

It doesn’t address the candidate by name, identify the position, or acknowledge the hours spent interviewing. For all its faults, though, it does one thing ghosting doesn’t: It gives the candidate an answer.

“Yes, even a brief rejection letter is important to job seekers,” Jasmine Escalera, a career expert at LiveCareer, told Fortune. “When a hiring manager lets the candidate know they have moved in another direction, it provides not only closure but also helps the job seeker know it’s time to turn their efforts to other opportunities.”

But closure is a low bar for someone who has already invested hours in the hiring process. “Candidates who completed several rounds of interviews deserve more than the same automated message sent to candidates who submitted a resume and didn’t interview,” Salemi said.

Fijneman-Ghielen shared the appreciative rejection letter used in her study. It acknowledged the applicant’s interest and effort, explained that other candidates had more relevant industry experience, encouraged future applications, and offered a discount code as a gesture of appreciation. One passage read:

“We understand that this may not be the news you were hoping for. However, we would like to emphasize that we were impressed by your skills and background and would like to ask you to keep an eye on our career page for future opportunities within organization X.”

Because the hiring scenario was fictional, the researchers had no information about the applicants’ actual qualifications. The letter showed how employers can express appreciation without providing individualized feedback.

She also pointed to Rituals, the Dutch beauty and lifestyle retailer. In a 2020 interview, Joan Carles Cifre, the company’s HR director for Spain and Portugal, said Rituals gave interviewees two miniature bath foams, one to keep and one to give away, as a way of carrying its brand philosophy of giving into recruiting.

For finalists, pick up the phone

For candidates who have already spent hours in interviews, Salemi believes employers should go a step further. When she worked in corporate recruiting, she made a point of calling candidates who had interviewed to tell them they hadn’t been selected.

Companies can make that manageable with standardized phone scripts or email templates that recruiters personalize, she said.

“Sometimes candidates actually thanked me for rejecting them even when they wanted that coveted job offer,” she said. They left knowing the company had taken the time to acknowledge them as individuals.

Salemi said the way employers treat candidates also offers a glimpse into their workplace culture. If a company can’t show appreciation for the time and effort someone invested in an interview, candidates may wonder how they would be treated as employees.

“Ultimately, rejecting candidates in a timely manner, especially when they reach the final rounds of interviews, isn’t just about protecting the employer’s reputation and/or brand,” Salemi said. “It’s about doing the right thing: Treating people with dignity and respect.”

This story was originally featured on Fortune.com